Written and checked by the USA Sod team · Published November 19, 2026

Choose St. Augustine for a shady yard that sees little foot traffic, and choose zoysia for a yard that gets played on, goes through dry spells or has colder winters. St. Augustine copes with shade but wears poorly and needs water to stay green. Zoysia takes wear, rides out drought by turning brown and dormant, and handles cold better, but it builds thatch and is tough to mow.
Customers often ask us which grass to pick, and some want one grass that handles both shade and dry weather. Both of these are warm-season grasses: in Texas the first frost fades them to a straw color, and they may go dormant over the winter. Bermuda is in the same group, and we cover those matchups in Bermuda grass vs. St. Augustine and zoysia vs. Bermuda grass. Here it is just St. Augustine against zoysia, one yard condition at a time.
Shade: St. Augustine
St. Augustine takes more shade than any other warm-season grass. Zoysia handles light to moderate shade, depending on the variety, but not as much as St. Augustine. Within St. Augustine, varieties differ in how they handle stress and pests. Floratam does not hold on in spots with under 6 hours of sun a day. Palmetto grows well in sun or part shade, though dense shade is too much for it. ProVista handles shade better than Floratam does. For the details, see which St. Augustine variety is best for shade and our St. Augustine grass guide.
Foot traffic: zoysia
St. Augustine has poor wear tolerance. It does not stand up to repeated foot traffic or cars. Well managed, zoysia forms a very dense lawn, and its traffic tolerance runs moderate to high. If kids, dogs or parties use the yard, read our guide to grass for high-traffic yards too.
Dry spells: zoysia, if you accept brown
Zoysia tolerates drought better than St. Augustine, but in its own way. In a typical drought it turns brown and goes dormant within about a week, then regains its green once rain or irrigation comes back. Letting it turn brown is a fair way to save water. St. Augustine needs water to stay green and healthy, and it may need irrigation through long dry stretches. When it runs short, it wilts, but some leaves stay green longer.
So for the shade plus drought question: in a yard with light shade and dry spells, zoysia covers both. In a shadier yard, choose St. Augustine and plan to water it.
Cold winters: zoysia, or Raleigh St. Augustine
St. Augustine has low cold tolerance, and severe winters can kill it, for example in the northern third of Texas. If you want it anyway, Raleigh is a cold-hardy St. Augustine variety. Zoysia's cold tolerance runs moderate to high, and Meyer zoysia has excellent winter hardiness. Expect a long brown season with zoysia, though: it loses color earlier in fall than any other lawn grass and is the last to turn green again in spring. See when zoysia grass goes dormant.
How each one looks and feels
St. Augustine has wide, coarse leaves and makes a dense turf in green to blue-green. Well managed, zoysia makes a very dense turf. Its leaf color and texture vary widely by variety, from coarse Empire to finer Emerald and Zeon, so it pays to know the types of zoysia grass before you choose.
Upkeep: mowing, thatch and weeds
Mowing. St. Augustine usually needs mowing every week in the growing season, and standard varieties are kept tall, at 3.5 to 4 inches, and a rotary mower works on it. Medium to coarse zoysias also want weekly mowing in summer, cut to 1.75 to 2.5 inches. Zoysia leaves hold extra lignin and silica compared with other lawn grasses, which makes them hard to cut, so keep the mower sharp.
Thatch. In the years after planting, zoysia usually builds up thick thatch, most of all with too much nitrogen. Plan to dethatch with a power rake or vertical mower once every one to two years. St. Augustine builds thatch too when it gets heavy fertilizer and water.
Weeds. A thick zoysia lawn resists weeds, and zoysia tolerates many weed killers. St. Augustine has few herbicide options for grassy weeds, so weed control can be harder.
More in our St. Augustine grass care and zoysia grass care guides.
Pests and disease
St. Augustine's main insect pest is the southern chinch bug, which leaves yellow to brown patches. Damage usually shows first as the weather warms, along sidewalks, next to buildings and in dry, sunny spots. Gray leaf spot and large patch are two of its major diseases. Zoysia's most troublesome disease is large patch, and because zoysia stays dormant so long, the damage can still show well into the next summer. Hunting billbugs, which feed on roots, can be a serious pest of zoysia.
Deciding, and ordering the sod
Shade and a gentle yard point to St. Augustine. Wear, dry spells and cold point to zoysia. Once you know which fits, plan the lawn in the lawn designer.
Sod is the quick way with either grass: it covers the whole area the day you lay it, and zoysia is slow to fill in from plugs compared with St. Augustine. Which varieties you can order depends on your ZIP code. For example, Palmetto, ProVista and Raleigh St. Augustine and Emerald, Palisade and Zeon Zoysia are commonly offered in Houston and San Antonio. Availability changes week to week, so enter your ZIP code for today's list.
Grass prices change from market to market; for what moves them, see what drives the price of zoysia vs. St. Augustine. Sod comes in full pallets because it is cut to order, and most pallets run between 400 and 600 square feet, depending on the farm that cuts your order. Delivery is a flat $200 on any order that includes sod, whether you order one pallet or ten.
Got a shady yard or a busy one? Pick the grass that fits it and check your ZIP code for the St. Augustine and zoysia sod offered near you, or call 1-866-886-2763.
Sources


